Book Review: The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo, Book 1, Denise Mina et al. (2012)

December 22nd, 2013 8:43 am by Kelly Garbato

Not nearly as engrossing as the books…

three out of five stars

(Trigger warning for discussions of rape.)

Stieg Larsson’s Millennium Trilogy gets the graphic novel treatment in this adaptation penned by Denise Mina. The first of two volumes (each book is to span two graphic novel collections) The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo, Book 1 covers the first book in the series. A murder mystery slash rape revenge story, The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo is not for the faint of heart: there’s quite a bit of violence (including violence of a sexual nature) and not a little sex and nudity. (I prefer to think of the series as The Men Who Hate Women Trilogy; after all, the series’ focus isn’t independent journalism, but MISOGYNY. Consequently, rape – or the threat of it – is present throughout the series.)

Book 1 covers the events of The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo from the time Henrik Vanger summons disgraced journalist Mikael Blomkvist to his estate on Hedeby Island, to the sexual assault and brutal rape of Lisbeth Salander at the hands of her court-appointed guardian, Nils Bjurman. By the end of this collection, Blomkvist has begun to serve his jail term for slandering businessman Hans-Erik Wennerström (another hater of women) while Lisbeth exacts revenge (in an equally brutal fashion) on her rapist. I won’t delve into the plot any further; I assume that, if you’re reading this, you’re already a fan of the books. (No? What are you waiting for?!)

The difficulty inherent in distilling such a long and complex story into just 312 pages of artwork is on display here, as Mina omits some scenes and combines others, sometimes changing the characters’ personalities in fundamental ways. For example, Cecilia Vanger propositions Blomkvist within hours of meeting him. As a result, comic book Cecilia seems like a woman who sleeps around, rather than a lonely, would-be divorcee who eventually finds her way to Blomkvist’s bed for some much-needed casual sex. Not that there’s anything wrong with having lots of sex, but that’s not who Cecilia is. And when she dumps Blomkvist at the beginning of his stint in jail, she seems much needier than Book Cecilia. Book Cecelia is much more reluctant to help him solve the mystery of Harriet’s disappearance, thus making her more ambivalent about Blomkvist in general.

Likewise, after the rape, Lisbeth is shown interacting with other people, most notably girlfriend Mimi. Book Lisbeth mostly went into hiding, at least until her visible wounds healed and she was able to formulate an action plan. Fiercely protective, Book Lisbeth didn’t want to be subjected to anyone’s questioning or pity, hence the seclusion. Comic book Lisbeth, while she still refuses to confide in anyone, seems much too comfortable displaying her vulnerabilities to others.

(For what it’s worth, I had the same problem with the American film adaptation: by story’s end, Lisbeth was telling a naked, post-coital Blomkvist about “all the evil” when, in the books, the audience was left to guess about Lisbeth’s childhood until well into The Girl Who Played with Fire. Simply put, Lisbeth would NEVER do that!)

While I understand the need to condense certain parts of the story, some of the changes are downright puzzling, since they don’t move the plot along any more quickly. Case in point: Lisbeth’s tattoo, which is changed from a small band around her ankle (reminiscent of the restraints Bjurman used during the rape) to the word “BYE” superimposed over a rose. The scene is actually a bit more drawn out in the graphic novel, as Lisbeth must spend several panels convincing the tattoo artist that this is not, in fact, a suicide note. Weird, right? Given the importance placed on tattoos throughout the trilogy, the alteration is not just confusing, but also doesn’t ring true.

(Bjurman’s minor tattoo change, on the other hand, is totally understandable: “I am a sadistic pig, a pervert, and a rapist” is shortened to the more manageable “I am a rapist.”)

The story, while recognizable, also lacks much of the suspense and sense of discovery of the original. I’ve seen episodes of Investigation Discovery that are more gripping in this regard.

As far as the artwork goes, it’s dark and moody, and well-suited for the book. My only complaint is that Lisbeth is much taller than she should be. In the books, she’s described as quite short, seemingly frail and almost childlike in stature. This is important because Lisbeth’s physical appearance impacts both her behavior (i.e., because she was constantly bullied as a child, she went on the offense in order to stave off attacks) and life circumstances (perhaps if she looked the part, the court might have rescinded Lisbeth’s guardianship when she became an adult). Yet, in one panel, Lisbeth appears to be nearly as tall as both Dragan Armansky and Dirch Frode.

Overall, I’m a little disappointed by the adaptation, but not enough so that I’ll stop reading it. I already own Book 2, so that’s moot; but neither have I cancelled my pre-order of The Girl Who Played With Fire, Book 1. This is a series that deserves much thicker comic books – but hey, I’ll take what I can get! Those who’ve never read the books might enjoy the comics a bit more, but that’s only because you’re not hip to the original materials. Seriously, check ‘em out.

(This review is also available on Amazon, Library Thing, and Goodreads. Please click through and vote it helpful if you’re so inclined!)

Be Sociable, Share!

Filed under , , , , , ,

One Response to “Book Review: The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo, Book 1, Denise Mina et al. (2012)”

  1. Book Review: The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo, Book 2, Denise Mina et al. (2013) » V for Vegan: Says:

    […] problems I had with the first volume carry over to the second one as well. In her attempt to boil a long and complicated story down to a […]

Leave a Reply