Roasted Banana Banana Ice Cream
Friday, May 17th, 2013

When a dessert sporting roasted bananas crossed my tumblr dash, my mind immediately went to ice cream – banana ice cream, that is. I wondered if anyone had tried roasting bananas prior to freezing them for ice cream and, if so, what effect this might have on the finished product. Right away I hit the net in search of recipes. (An by “right away” I mean several weeks later. Procrastination, it’s my strong suit.)
Turns out there are as many ways to make roasted banana ice cream as there are bananas in a bunch. Let’s start with the roasting: you can slice and freeze the bananas and then roast them – or slice and roast them, and then pop ‘em in the freezer (which, incidentally, is the method I use here). You can roast them in their peels or naked. The bananas can function as the base in true banana ice cream form, or be used as flavoring for a milk base (non-dairy, in our case). Food processor or ice cream machine, take your pick. Or mix them half and half with unroasted bananas! Is your head spinning yet?
In the end, I went with the slice and roast method, and it worked quite well. The brown sugar and margarine congealed into a sticky sweetener which hardened nicely when chilled. As with regular old banana ice cream, you want to use overripe bananas – just not quite as brown and mushy as usual (too hard to slice!). The bananas shrink down quite a bit during roasting, so you’ll end up with a little less ice cream than normal; seven bananas yields about three quarters of a quart, whereas five unroasted bananas usually amounts to a full quart of ice cream for me.
The taste of roasted bananas is difficult to describe. It tastes…roasted? Kind of a bit richer than regular old bananas. The whiskey is optional, but is super-neat in that it prevents the ice cream from freezing solid. Instead, it exists in this perpetual state of soft serve. Definitely a bonus in my book.

When a dessert sporting roasted bananas crossed my tumblr dash, my mind immediately went to ice cream – banana ice cream, that is. I wondered if anyone had tried roasting bananas prior to freezing them for ice cream and, if so, what effect this might have on the finished product. Right away I hit the net in search of recipes. (An by “right away” I mean several weeks later. Procrastination, it’s my strong suit.)
Turns out there are as many ways to make roasted banana ice cream as there are bananas in a bunch. Let’s start with the roasting: you can slice and freeze the bananas and then roast them – or slice and roast them, and then pop ‘em in the freezer (which, incidentally, is the method I use here). You can roast them in their peels or naked. The bananas can function as the base in true banana ice cream form, or be used as flavoring for a milk base (non-dairy, in our case). Food processor or ice cream machine, take your pick. Or mix them half and half with unroasted bananas! Is your head spinning yet?
In the end, I went with the slice and roast method, and it worked quite well. The brown sugar and margarine congealed into a sticky sweetener which hardened nicely when chilled. As with regular old banana ice cream, you want to use overripe bananas – just not quite as brown and mushy as usual (too hard to slice!). The bananas shrink down quite a bit during roasting, so you’ll end up with a little less ice cream than normal; seven bananas yields about three quarters of a quart, whereas five unroasted bananas usually amounts to a full quart of ice cream for me.
The taste of roasted bananas is difficult to describe. It tastes…roasted? Kind of a bit richer than regular old bananas. The whiskey is optional, but is super-neat in that it prevents the ice cream from freezing solid. Instead, it exists in this perpetual state of soft serve. Definitely a bonus in my book.






























